Extraterrestrial Communication Search: The Breakthrough Initiative

The Breakthrough Initiatives were first announced to the public on July 20, 2015, at London’s Royal Society by physicist Stephen Hawking. The announcement included an open letter co-signed by multiple scientists, including Hawking, expressing support for an intensified search for extraterrestrial communications.

During the public launch, Hawking said: 

In an infinite Universe, there must be other life. There is no bigger question. It is time to commit to finding the answer”.

The Royal Society, formally The Royal Society of London for Improving Natural Knowledge, is a learned society and the United Kingdom’s National Academy of Sciences. The Society fulfills several roles, such as promoting science and its benefits, recognizing excellence in science, supporting outstanding science, providing scientific advice for policy, education, and public engagement, and fostering international and global cooperation.

The Society was founded on November 28, 1660. King Charles II granted The Society a royal charter as The Royal Society. It is the oldest continuously existing scientific academy in the world.

 

Russian tycoon Yuri Milner created the Breakthrough Initiatives to search for intelligent extraterrestrial life in the Universe and consider a plan for transmitting messages into space.

The Breakthrough Initiatives Project for Extraterrestrial Intelligence (ETI) is a groundbreaking scientific endeavor to detect signs of intelligent life beyond Earth. ETI is a different, lesser-known, and lesser-publicized program than the SETI Institute. However, it is equally important. 

The SETI Institute and the Project Breakthrough Initiative have significantly contributed to the search for extraterrestrial intelligence. While the SETI Institute focuses on detecting and analyzing potential signals from alien civilizations, the Project Breakthrough initiative adopts a more proactive approach by planning interstellar missions. Although the methodologies differ, the common goal of unraveling the mysteries of the Universe and determining if life exists beyond our planet binds these initiatives together.

The ETI program brings together the world’s brightest minds and cutting-edge technologies to search for evidence of civilizations elsewhere in the Universe. Yuri Milner and Stephen Hawking launched part of the Breakthrough Initiatives, Project Listen, in 2015. It is funded by the Foundation established by Yuri and Julia Milner. 

Stephen Hawking is a household name in the world of physics. Yuri Milner is not. Yuri Borisovich Milner is a lesser-known (by the public) Soviet-born Israeli entrepreneur, investor, physicist, and scientist. Milner is a fascinating man. The Extraterrestrial Communication Group will soon post an article about him on our Hall of Fame Library page.

Breakthrough Listen is a $100 million program of astronomical observations and analysis. The program is the most comprehensive in search of evidence of technological civilizations in the Universe. The program utilizes some of the world’s largest and most advanced telescopes across five continents. It surveys targets, including one million nearby stars, the entire galactic plane, and 100 nearby galaxies at a wide range of radio and optical frequency bands.

The Breakthrough Listen program aims to survey over a million nearby stars, as well as the center of our galaxy and neighboring galaxies, in search of radio and laser signals that could indicate the presence of extraterrestrial intelligence. By using a powerful combination of advanced telescopes, receivers, and signal analysis algorithms, the project seeks to detect and decipher potential messages sent by other civilizations. On the other hand, the Breakthrough Message program focuses on formulating and transmitting a universal message to possible extraterrestrial civilizations. 

In addition to the cutting-edge technology employed in the search for ETI, the Breakthrough Initiatives Project also greatly emphasizes international collaboration. The project has forged partnerships with leading institutions and organizations worldwide, fostering a global effort to pursue extraterrestrial intelligence. Breakthrough Listen can maximize its chances of success and ensure that all corners of the sky are being diligently searched for signs of advanced civilizations by sharing resources, knowledge, and data.

The team behind Breakthrough Listen has collaborated with some of the world’s most powerful telescopes, such as the

Green Bank Telescope in West Virginia, USA, and the Parkes Observatory in Australia.

These telescopes have advanced receivers and data processing systems, enabling them to detect even the faintest signals from distant star systems. 

Breakthrough Message is a $1 million competition to design a message representing Earth, life, and humanity that another civilization could understand. The aim is to encourage Society to think together as one world and to spark public debate about the ethics of sending messages beyond Earth.

Avoiding potential misunderstandings or unintended consequences is the challenge to composing a message that an advanced civilization can understand. This program raises critical ethical questions regarding the potential impact of human contact with extraterrestrial intelligence, highlighting the need for careful consideration and international collaboration when transmitting messages into the cosmos.

With a focus on exploration, technology development, and international collaboration, the Breakthrough Initiatives Project for ETI is taking humanity one step closer to answering the age-old question: Are we alone in the cosmos? 

One of the most notable examples is the Breakthrough Starshot project, co-founded by Mark Zuckerberg, which aims to send ultra-fast, lightweight spacecraft to nearby star systems. By utilizing light sails and laser propulsion, these spacecrafts could reach speeds of up to 20% the speed of light.

This groundbreaking technology opens up the possibility of exploring exoplanets and their potential inhabitants within our lifetimes.

The technology it develops could revolutionize our ability to search for advanced civilizations. The Breakthrough Watch project aims to identify and characterize Earth-sized, rocky planets around Alpha Centauri and other stars within 20 light-years of Earth. Breakthrough plans to send a mission to Saturn’s moon, Enceladus, in search of life in its warm ocean, and in 2018, signed a partnership agreement with NASA for the project.

Beyond the scientific and technological aspects, the Breakthrough Initiatives Project for ETI also addresses the societal implications of discovering intelligent life beyond Earth. The Breakthrough Message program, for example, explores the ethical considerations of sending messages to potential extraterrestrial civilizations.

The project engages with scholars, ethicists, and the public to discuss interstellar communication’s potential risks and benefits. The project ensures that any possible encounter with ETI is approached responsibly and thoughtfully by fostering these discussions and considering the long-term consequences of contact. 

The Breakthrough Initiatives Project for ETI has amassed significant attention and support from the scientific community and the public. It represents a paradigm shift in our approach to the search for extraterrestrial intelligence, focusing on a comprehensive and multidisciplinary effort. The project’s commitment to international collaboration, cutting-edge technology, and ethical considerations sets it apart from previous endeavors in this field. 

However, it is essential to recognize the challenges and limitations faced by the Breakthrough Initiatives Project for ETI. The vastness of the cosmos and the limits of current technology contribute to the project’s uncertainties. Yet, these challenges make the Breakthrough Initiatives Project for ETI so important. 

Critics of the Breakthrough Initiative Project will argue that the chances of success are minuscule. They question the justification for investing significant financial and intellectual resources in a project that may yield no concrete results. However, proponents argue that the quest to explore the unknown has always driven human progress and that the potential discovery of extraterrestrial intelligence could transform our species, fundamentally altering our understanding of the Universe and ourselves.

One of the key strengths of the Breakthrough Initiative Project is its international scope and collaborative approach. Leading scientists worldwide have joined forces to contribute their expertise and resources, forming a global network of researchers dedicated to the search for extraterrestrial intelligence. This collaborative effort ensures that a diverse range of perspectives and methodologies are employed to maximize the chances of success. Furthermore, the project encourages open data sharing and transparency. 

All data collected by the Breakthrough Listen program is publicly available, allowing researchers worldwide to analyze and contribute to the efforts. This open approach can accelerate scientific progress by fostering collaboration and stimulating innovative ideas.

University of Oxford Partners with Breakthrough Prize Foundation in Search for Life Beyond Earth

The University of Oxford and the Breakthrough Prize Foundation announced a new scientific partnership to find evidence of technology signatures beyond our planet. Oxford will be the international headquarters for the Breakthrough Listen initiative.

The partnership will advance the scope and reach of the Listen program, putting the UK at the forefront of this rapidly growing field and injecting significant resources into technology and software development at the University of Oxford’s Department of Physics.

The University of Oxford’s Department of Physics will be the new international headquarters for the Breakthrough Listen program. Listen’s arrival at Oxford will enhance existing research strands, introduce a new direction for research, and support significant technological innovation. This new partnership includes:

  • Hardware, software, and theoretical advances in radio astrophysics, with a focus on the Square Kilometre Array, a global effort to deliver a transformational radio telescope array by 2030
  • The search for life on extrasolar planets, including a focus on our nearest neighbors
  • Detection of astrophysical transients and anomalies in optical transient surveys, including the vast new LSST survey to be delivered by the Rubin Observatory in 2024
  • Development of new, cutting-edge machine learning (AI) techniques to search the vast amounts of incoming astronomical signals for anomalies
  • Exploring the possibility of using the lunar farside as an interference-free site for radio astronomy

Principal Investigator Dr. Andrew Siemion will continue to lead the program as part of Oxford’s Astrophysics Department. The partnership preserves existing relationships with the University of California at Berkeley, the University of Manchester, the University of Cambridge, the SKA Observatory, the SETI Institute, and other global partners.

The Breakthrough Prize Foundation donated $500,000 million to a consortium of universities led by Tel Aviv University. It also included the Hebrew University of Jerusalem and the Technion as part of a $3 million fund pledged to support scientists who have been forced to flee from Ukraine; the universities are creating a unique program of emergency fellowships to enable the scientists to maintain their livelihoods and continue their research while the conflict continues.

The program will create emergency fellowships, enabling recipients to continue their scientific studies in Israel. As well as accommodation and living expenses, the program will also cover some work-related costs, such as conference trips.

It is estimated that Israel will receive up to 15,000 refugees from the conflict in Ukraine —15,000 refugees in addition to those able to emigrate under the country’s Law of Return. With millions of civilians already displaced and Ukrainian universities and research centers severely impacted by the war, that number will undoubtedly include many scientists. The Foundation and the three universities hope the funds will help sustain researchers and their families and allow them to continue contributing to the world’s knowledge during the crisis.

The Breakthrough Initiative Project for Extraterrestrial Intelligence represents a pioneering endeavor to search for signs of intelligent life beyond Earth. Through its comprehensive approach, advanced technology, and international collaboration, this project aims to answer the age-old question of whether we are alone in the universe. Skeptics will question the feasibility and justification of the project. However, the project’s potential impact on our understanding of the cosmos and our place within the cosmos must also be considered by these skeptics.

We must continue our search for extraterrestrial communication to satisfy the intrinsic human curiosity, the pursuit of scientific knowledge, and the potential benefits such a discovery could bring. The quest meets our fundamental curiosity, drives scientific advancements, and holds considerable potential benefits for humanity.

Ultimately, the quest for extraterrestrial communication represents an intrepid pursuit that transcends national and cultural boundaries, inspiring us to explore the unknown and expand the horizons of human knowledge. With the Breakthrough Initiative Project, humanity takes a bold step towards unraveling the mysteries of the universe and finding and communicating with our cosmic companions.

Sources:

  1. Breakthrough Initiatives website: Breakthrough Initiatives
  2. org. October 26, 2021. Breakthrough Listen project releases analysis of previously detected signal.
  3. Breakthrough Initiatives
  4. University of Oxford, Department of Physics. October 2023. University of Oxford partners with Breakthrough Prize Foundation in search for life beyond Earth

The Relationships between Extraterrestrial Communication, Religious Faith and Science

The interplay between Christian faiths, the existence of extraterrestrial life, and the application of science have been topics of great debate and speculation throughout human history.

While science aims to investigate and explain the natural world, religious faith delves into the supernatural and the realms beyond human understanding. This relates to but differs from articles I have written about ET Compatibility with Christianity and the Crossroads of God and science.  

Divine Creation and Intelligent Design Religious faith asserts that a divine being created the universe, particularly within Abrahamic religions. According to this perspective, Earth and humans hold a unique creation position. The belief in divine Creation often leads to the assumption that humans are the sole repository of God’s grace and intelligence. Consequently, the possibility of extraterrestrial life becomes a theological challenge, questioning the centrality of human existence in the cosmic plan. 

Expanding the concept of Creation, however, religious interpretations can also evolve to accommodate the idea of extraterrestrial life. Exponents of religious faith argue that a compassionate and omnipotent creator could have fashioned life on other celestial bodies, expanding God’s Creation beyond Earth. This more inclusive understanding acknowledges the vastness of the universe and the potential diversity of life within it without negating religious principles.

The Drake Equation and the Fermi Paradox Scientific inquiry, guided by empirical evidence and mathematical calculations, explore the possibility of extraterrestrial existence. Using tools like the Drake Equation, which estimates the number of civilizations in our galaxy capable of communication, scientists attempt to quantify the likelihood of encountering intelligent extraterrestrial life. 

Astrobiology and the Search for Life Astrobiology is an interdisciplinary scientific field that studies life’s origins and existence in the universe. Through the examination of extremophiles, the search for exoplanets within a star’s habitable zone, and discovering of organic compounds, astrobiologists strive to uncover the conditions necessary for life as we know it.

The existence of extraterrestrial life raises theological questions related to the nature of God, God’s relationship with Creation, and the purpose of humanity. Religious scholars and theologians engage in nuanced debates to reconcile religious tenets with emerging scientific discoveries. The existence of extraterrestrial life inspires new theological insights, calling for a reinterpretation of traditional religious texts and doctrines. 

The discovery of extraterrestrial life challenges theological perspectives and presents ethical dilemmas. Concepts such as stewardship, compassion, and coexistence by various religious traditions can inform discussions around the responsible exploration and potential interaction with extraterrestrial life forms. Religion can contribute to the ethical frameworks needed to guide our actions in a universe that extends beyond the boundaries of Earth. 

The trend in the number of people of faith in the world looks like this: Notice that:

  1. The combined Abrahamic Religions (Christianity, Islam, and Judaism) are the overwhelming majority.
  2. The trend in the population of Muslims and Christians draws closer to equality.
  3. The number of Christians changes by only 1%
  4. The Jewish population has not changed from 0.2%.
  5. The number of Muslims increased by 7%
  6. All other religions remain equal or show a slight decrease.
  7. There is a decrease in the number of unaffiliated people. Considering item 5 above, this means that the majority of people who change or find faith will become Muslim. 

Christianity is the Abrahamic monotheistic religion with the most followers. It developed in the first century CE out of Judaism. Christians adhere to revelations described in a series of canonical texts, which include the Old Testament. The Old Testament is comprised of texts that were inherited from Judaism. The New Testament contains the Gospels of Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John (narratives on the life and teachings of Jesus), as well as events and teachings of the early Christian churches (e.g., Acts of the Apostles, letters by Paul), and Revelation, a prophetic book on the end times.

The relationship between science and faith is described in something called the two-books metaphor[1]. God revealed Godself through the “Book of Nature,” with its orderly laws, and the “Book of Scripture,” with its historical narratives and accounts of miracles.

 The Book of Nature is not an actual “book” but a religious and philosophical concept originating in the Latin Middle Ages. The metaphorical book explores the relationship between religion and science. The concept views nature as a book for knowledge and understanding. Early theologians, such as St. Paul, believed the Book of Nature was a source of God’s revelation to humankind. He believed that when read alongside sacred Scripture, the “book” and the study of God’s creations would lead to knowledge of God himself. It is the root of Pantheism.

Pantheism is the philosophical, religious belief that reality, the universe, the cosmos, and nature are identical to divinity and a Supreme Being or entity. The physical universe is thus understood as an immanent deity, still expanding and creating, which has existed since the beginning of time.

The term pantheist designates one who holds that everything constitutes a unity, and that this unity is divine. The unity consists of an all-encompassing manifested god or goddess. All astronomical objects are viewed as parts of a sole deity.

Pantheist belief does not recognize a distinct personal god, anthropomorphic or otherwise. Instead, it characterizes a broad range of doctrines differing in relationships between reality and divinity. Pantheistic concepts date back thousands of years, and pantheistic elements have been identified in various religious traditions. The term pantheism was coined by mathematician Joseph Raphson in 1697. Since that time, it has been used to describe the beliefs of multiple people and organizations.

Pantheism was popularized in Western culture as a theology and philosophy based on the work of 17th-century philosopher Baruch Spinoza, particularly his Book Ethics. Philosopher and cosmologist Giordano Bruno also took a pantheistic stance in the 16th century. Advaita Vedanta, a school of Hindu philosophy, is thought to be similar to Pantheism in Western philosophy.

This type of revelation is commonly referred to as a general revelation. The concept corresponds to the early Greek philosophical belief that humans, as part of a coherent universe, can understand the design of the natural world through reason. Philosophers, theologians, and scholars frequently referenced this concept.

The phrase’s first known use was by Galileo, who used the term when writing about how “the book of nature can become readable and comprehensible.”

It has been argued that the Book of Nature was more accessible since Scripture requires literacy. Illiterates and literates could both read the Book of Nature. During the Middle Ages, scholars and theologians began to claim that the Book of Nature needed to be more straightforward to read.

Given that original sin has marred our reason and perception, what conclusions could humans legitimately draw about ultimate reality? It was argued that sin has clouded human reason so much that the Book of Nature has become unreadable and that Scripture is needed to aid as it contains teachings about the world.

Christian authors in science and religion continue to debate how these two books interrelate. Concordism is the attempt to interpret Scripture in the light of modern science. It is an approach to Bible interpretation, where one expects that the Bible predicted scientific theories, such as the Big Bang theory or evolutionary theory. Some will argue many scientific-sounding statements in the Bible are scientifically invalid. Any accurate integration between the Book of Nature and Scripture will require more nuance and sophistication. 

Several Christian authors have attempted to integrate science and religion, making integration a prevalent view on the relationship between science and religion. Historians have argued that Christianity was instrumental to the development of Western science. They maintain that the doctrine of original sin played a crucial role. It was said that there was a widespread belief in the early modern period that Adam, before the Fall, had superior senses, intellect, and understanding.

Because of the Fall, human senses became duller, our ability to make correct inferences diminished, and nature became less intelligible. After the Fall, humans can no longer exclusively rely on experience-based reasoning to understand nature. They must supplement their reasoning and senses with observation through specialized instruments like microscopes and telescopes.

Another theological development that may have facilitated the rise of science was the Condemnation of Paris (1277). The Condemnation forbade teaching and reading natural philosophical views considered sinful, such as Aristotle’s physical treatises. As a result, the Condemnation opened up intellectual space to think beyond ancient Greek natural philosophy. 

By embracing the establishment of two-way communication with intelligent extraterrestrial life, religious faith and science can evolve and deepen, offering fresh perspectives on divine Creation. Likewise, science can benefit from incorporating the profound questions and insights that religious faith provides.

The inherent complementary nature of these realms encourages us to appreciate the awe-inspiring beauty and complexity of a universe that transcends our current comprehension. Let us embark on this journey of exploration with open hearts and curious minds, celebrating the unity that can emerge from the intersections of faith, extraterrestrial communication, and science.

References:

1.De Cruz, Helen, “Religion and Science,” The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (fall 2022 Edition), Edward N. Zalta & Uri Nodelman 

2.Tanzella-Nitti, Giuseppe, 2005, “The Two Books Before the Scientific Revolution”Perspectives on Science and Christian Faith, 57(3): 225–248.

3.Wikipedia – multiple references

World Peace through Extraterrestrial Communication

The quest for extraterrestrial communication has captivated human imagination for hundreds of years. Beyond the fascination with the unknown, there lies a profound possibility that the pursuit and achievement of contact with extraterrestrial civilizations could foster global unity and world peace.

Such an achievement is one thing that could prevent humanity from destroying itself. This idea does not consider the various “End of Days” prophesies by religious sects. I ponder these overwhelming concepts often. It seems that prophesies and establishing extraterrestrial communication are on a collision course.

The idea that we are not alone in the universe transcends geopolitical boundaries, cultural differences, and historical conflicts, offering a shared endeavor that redefines our collective sense of identity and purpose. 

Regardless of nationality, religion, or ideology, the prospect of communicating with beings from another world could serve as the common thread. The thread binds us together as people of Earth. The shared endeavor to decipher signals from the cosmos encourages a sense of global community. It emphasizes the importance of our common humanity over our differences.

Confirmation of intelligent extraterrestrial life via the establishment of communication could instigate a profound shift in perspective, transcending the limitations of an Earth-bound outlook. When faced with the vastness of the cosmos, humanity should recognize the need for cooperation to address shared challenges such as environmental sustainability, climate change, and resource management. This broader cosmic perspective diminishes the significance of terrestrial conflicts, fostering a renewed commitment to working together for the greater good.

The vastness of the cosmos and the prospect of discovery have captured the imaginations of countless individuals, from scientists and engineers to artists, philosophers, theologians, and poets. However, the impact of space exploration extends far beyond the realm of scientific curiosity and cultural inspiration. It plays (or should play) a significant role in promoting world peace.

The history of space exploration is marked by intense competition and rivalry, particularly during the Cold War era. The United States and the Soviet Union engaged in a high-stakes race to achieve various milestones in space, from launching the first artificial satellite to landing humans on the Moon. While this competition undoubtedly fueled technological advancements and accelerated the pace of space exploration, it also served as a means of demonstrating national prowess and asserting dominance on the global stage. I composed and posted an article entitled Who Owns Outer Space in April 2023.

During a speech before the United Nations in 1987, President Ronald Reagan spoke longingly for the world unity that would happen if we made extraterrestrial contact. He said:

“We may need some outside universal threat to recognize this common bond. How quickly our differences worldwide would vanish if we faced an alien threat outside this world”.

The flavor of Regan’s comment implies conflict with ETs. The result would be the same if the first contact ETs were more on the side of friendly. People who speculate on this matter have mixed opinions. Some are convinced that ET contact would be a hostile invasion and colonization. Others are confident that establishing ET communication would be more of an invitation to join the community of the universe in a peaceful and friendly way. In either case, it behooves the people of Earth to come together in defense of a new enemy or to share a universe full of new friends.

“Each friend represents a world in us, not born until they arrive, and it is only by this meeting that a new world is born.” Anais Nin

Despite its competitive origins, space exploration has evolved into a more collaborative endeavor in recent decades. For example, the International Space Station (ISS) stands as a testament to the power of international cooperation in pursuing a common goal. 

Launched in 1998, the ISS is a joint project involving five space agencies: NASA (United States), Roscosmos (Russia), JAXA (Japan), ESA (Europe), and CSA (Canada). Astronauts from 19 countries have lived and worked together on the ISS, conducting research and experiments that benefit humanity.

This spirit of collaboration extends beyond the ISS to other areas of space exploration as well. For instance, the European Space Agency’s Mars Express mission has been sharing data with NASA’s Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter, leading to a better understanding of the Martian environment. Similarly, the joint NASA-ESA Cassini-Huygens mission to Saturn and its moons has yielded groundbreaking discoveries and fostered a strong partnership between the two space agencies.

The collaborative nature of modern space exploration has the potential to promote world peace by fostering a sense of unity and shared purpose among nations. As countries work together to achieve common goals in space, they can build trust and strengthen diplomatic ties. Moreover, the challenges of space exploration require the pooling of resources, knowledge, and expertise, which can lead to increased interdependence and cooperation among nations.

In addition to fostering international collaboration, space exploration can contribute to world peace by shifting the focus away from Earth-bound conflicts and rivalries. As humanity ventures further into the cosmos, the vastness of space can serve as a reminder of the insignificance of our terrestrial disputes.

The famous “pale blue dot” photograph taken by the Voyager 1 spacecraft in 1990, which shows Earth as a speck in the vastness of space, underscores this point. Astronauts who have experienced the “overview effect,” a cognitive shift in awareness that occurs when viewing Earth from a distance, often report a profound sense of interconnectedness and a newfound appreciation for the fragility of our planet.

Pursuing space exploration can help redirect national resources and priorities away from military spending and toward more peaceful endeavors. As countries invest in space programs and scientific research, they may be less inclined to engage in armed conflict and more focused on addressing global challenges, such as climate change, resource scarcity, and disease.

The impact of space exploration on world peace is multifaceted and significant. By fostering international collaboration, shifting our perspective on Earth-bound conflicts, and redirecting resources toward peaceful pursuits, space exploration has the potential to serve as a powerful force for unity and peace in an increasingly interconnected world. As humanity continues to push the boundaries of our knowledge and capabilities in space, we must also recognize and embrace opportunities to promote peace and understanding among nations.

Establishing communication with intelligent extraterrestrial beings is the global event needed to accelerate this world community concept. The pursuit of extraterrestrial contact requires advanced technological capabilities and scientific expertise. Collaborative efforts in developing and deploying cutting-edge technologies for interstellar communication could lead to unprecedented international cooperation. Shared resources, expertise, and knowledge exchange could become integral components of a global scientific community working towards a common goal, creating a bridge for diplomatic, religious, and technological collaboration.

Pursuing extraterrestrial communication prompts humanity to recognize common threats and challenges beyond national borders. Rather than competing for supremacy on Earth, nations should channel their resources and collective intelligence toward addressing challenges that affect the entire planet. This shift in focus from internal rivalry to external collaboration will pave the way for a more peaceful and cooperative world. Nations must develop a mutually acceptable and well-thought strategy for dealing with how we will interact with intelligent extraterrestrials. I wrote an article on the subject in December 2022 entitled Missing Plan for Extraterrestrial First Contact

Presenting this ET world peace concept does not imply that cooperation and peace require a one-world government or religious faith. Interacting with extraterrestrial civilizations invites reflection on our cultural diversity. As the world unites in the pursuit of cosmic communication, cultural exchange and understanding could flourish. Sharing our cultural heritage, values, and traditions may strengthen the bonds between nations, foster empathy, and cultivate a deeper appreciation for the richness of human civilization. 

Human nature, being what it is, suggests that there will likely be those who refuse to cooperate as they have for centuries. The world would need to figure out how to deal with these outliers for the greater good of all nations with the desire for world cooperation and peace. 

While the quest for extraterrestrial communication is ongoing, its potential implications for world peace are profound. The shared pursuit of contact with extraterrestrial intelligence allows humanity to transcend earthly conflicts and unite in a joint venture that reflects our collective curiosity and aspirations.

By fostering global collaboration, encouraging a broader perspective, and emphasizing our shared humanity, the endeavor to communicate with extraterrestrial civilizations could contribute to a more harmonious and peaceful world. The work done in the spirit of sharing resources for space exploration to date is a good start.

When we contact the community of intelligent life beyond Earth, we may find the common threads that weave us together as a people of Earth. Extraterrestrial communication could be the bridge to global harmony.

Achieving extraterrestrial communication would be a powerful motivator in establishing a world community with a common goal.

Sources:

  • Ts2. The impact of space exploration on world peace. Marcin Frąckiewicz.  20 June 2023
  • Wikipedia: Potential cultural impact of extraterrestrial contact
  • Washington Post. Contacting aliens could end all life on Earth. Let’s stop trying. Mark Buchanan. June 10, 1921
  • Science Direct. The Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence: A Realpolitik Consideration. Kenneth W. Wisian. May 2020

 

 

 

Qualcomm Pioneer Franklin Antonio: Funding the Search for Extraterrestrial Communication

Suppose you have doubts about the commitment to the search for extraterrestrial communication. In that case, this article will assure you that some of the most intelligent people in the world remain committed to investigating and funding the ongoing extraterrestrial communication efforts.   

The SETI (Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence) Institute, a non-profit

scientific research organization, announced on November 8, 2023, a philanthropic gift of $200m from the estate of Franklin Antonio. Antonio was a visionary supporter and catalyst of the SETI Institute’s work for over 12 years. Antonio passed away on May 13, 2022, leaving an extraordinary legacy to enable breakthrough science in the search for intelligent life beyond our world. 

Franklin Antonio, a visionary engineer, entrepreneur, and co-founder of Qualcomm, played a pivotal role in shaping the landscape of modern telecommunications. His innovative contributions to the field have transformed how we communicate. He laid the foundation for the development of cutting-edge technologies that define the digital era.

Born in 1958, Franklin Antonio earned his bachelor’s and master’s degrees in electrical engineering from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) in the early 1980s. After completing his education, Antonio, Irwin Jacobs, Andrew Viterbi, and five other industry veterans co-founded Qualcomm in 1985. The purpose of establishing the company was to revolutionize wireless communications by developing advanced digital communication technologies.

One of Antonio’s groundbreaking achievements at Qualcomm was his role in developing Code Division Multiple Access (CDMA) technology.

CDMA represented a paradigm shift in wireless communication by introducing a digital approach to cellular networks, offering improved capacity, increased call quality, and enhanced security compared to traditional analog systems. This innovation laid the groundwork for the widespread adoption of digital cellular technology, contributing significantly to the evolution of 2G, 3G, and subsequent generations of mobile networks.

Antonio’s work extended beyond CDMA, encompassing a broad range of technologies integral to our interconnected world. He has been instrumental in advancing signal processing algorithms and semiconductor design and developing foundational technologies for 4G LTE and beyond. His commitment to driving innovation in wireless communications has positioned Qualcomm as a global leader in the industry.

In addition to his technical contributions, Franklin Antonio has played a vital role in guiding Qualcomm’s strategic direction. While serving on the company’s Board of Directors, he was involved in shaping Qualcomm’s initiatives in areas such as the Internet of Things (IoT), artificial intelligence, and 5G technology. These strategic moves underscore his foresight and commitment to staying at the forefront of technological innovation.

 Franklin Antonio’s dedication to education is recognized beyond his corporate responsibilities. He has been actively involved in supporting STEM (Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics) education initiatives and has served on the advisory boards of educational institutions. Antonio’s commitment to fostering the next generation of innovators reflects his belief in the transformative power of education and technology.

In acknowledgment of his outstanding contributions, Franklin Antonio has received numerous accolades and honors.

He is a National Academy of Engineering member and a fellow of the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE). Antonio was awarded the IEEE Alexander Graham Bell Medal for his contributions to the communication industry. SETI president and CEO Bill Diamond Seti told The Register:

“SETI has an annual operating budget that averages between just $25 and $30 million. Antonio’s gift is nearly ten times what the organization needs to operate for a year”“We intend to invest the funds and treat it like an endowment to fund various institute programs permanently. These programs include but are not limited to our SETI research. ”

“SETI programs are only eligible for minimal federal funding, with most of its support from philanthropists and private donors like Antonio. “Guided by our core mission and Franklin Antonio’s vision, we can elevate and expedite our research and make discoveries to benefit all humanity for generations to come.” “In his memory, the SETI Institute will continue its pursuit of one of the biggest and most profound questions in all of science, a question as old as humanity itself – are we alone in the universe?”

The SETI Institute, founded in 1984, is a multi-disciplinary research and education organization. Their mission is to lead humanity’s quest to understand the origins and prevalence of life and intelligence in the universe and share that knowledge with the world. 

SETI’s research encompasses the physical and biological sciences. It also leverages data analytics, machine learning, and advanced signal detection technologies. 

The SETI Institute is a distinguished research partner for industry, academia, and government agencies, including NASA, the Department of Energy, and the National Science Foundation. With more than 100 scientists actively conducting research across 173 separate programs, the SETI Institute explores six key science disciplines: 

      • Astronomy and Astrophysics
      • Exoplanets
      • Planetary Exploration
      • Astrobiology
      • Climate and bio-geoscience
      • The Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence

Antonio’s gift enables the SETI Institute to undertake more missions and expand research priorities to push the boundaries of human knowledge in exploring life beyond our planet and the origins of life here on Earth. Dr. Nathalie Cabrol, Director of the Carl Sagan Center for Research, stated:

This gift will impact all research domains of the SETI Institute. It will give our teams the freedom to pursue their science priorities and examine their research’s technological, philosophical, and societal impact on our daily lives here on Earth.”

Franklin Antonio’s journey as a co-founder of Qualcomm and his trailblazing work in telecommunications has left an indelible mark on how we communicate in the modern world.

His vision, technical acumen, and commitment to innovation have propelled Qualcomm to the forefront of the industry. His legacy continues to shape the trajectory of wireless communications. We stand on the brink of the 5G era and beyond. Franklin Antonio’s contributions serve as a testament to the transformative power of technology and the enduring impact of visionary leaders in telecommunications.

This article leads me to reiterate a hypothesis I have put forth several times. The theory states that the ET communication search has yet to follow the scientific method. It is time to revise the experiment. That experiment is outlined in my first book, Extraterrestrial Communication Code. Antonio’s gift to SETI provides the resources to undertake the proposed experiment. The cost is insignificant and only a tiny fraction of the gifted funds. The revised investigation is also consistent with SETI’s stated intentions for using those funds. Imagine the possibilities.

Sources:

Wikipedia

The Register. Science: Late Qualcomm cofounder teleports $200M into SETI to bankroll hunt for alien life.

SETI Institute Press Release. November 8, 2023: $200m Gift Propels Scientific Research in the Search for Life Beyond Earth

Aglaonice: Women of Antiquity Illuminating the Ancient Skies

Throughout ancient history, the luminaries of astronomy often shine with the brilliance of distant stars. Among these celestial scholars, the name of Aglaonice emerges as a beacon of light. She challenged the historical shadow that often veils the contributions of women in ancient science. 

 Aglaonice, a Greek astronomer from the 2nd century BCE, is a testament to the tenacity of ancient women who ventured into the cosmos, seeking knowledge and understanding.

She was a Greek astronomer and thaumaturge. Thaumaturgy is the purported capability of a magician to work magic or other paranormal events or a saint to perform miracles. Thaumaturge translates into English as wonderworking.

A practitioner of thaumaturgy is a “thaumaturge,” “thaumaturgist,” “thaumaturgus,” “miracle worker,” or “wonderworker.” A ‘saint’ is defined as having an exceptional degree of holiness, enlightenment, likeness, or closeness to God and may be claimed to have performed miracles. These miracles are generally defined as exceptional events or deeds not within the normative means of natural or human power. This in contrast to being of some supernatural or preternatural manner. The definition of a ‘miracle,’ like the definition of a ‘saint,’ will vary among separate religions, sects, and schools.

Aglaonice, also known as Aganice of Thessaly, is cited as the first female astronomer in ancient Greece. The writings of Plutarch and Apollonius of Rhodes refer to her as the daughter of King Hegetor of Thessaly or Hegemon. Her ability to make the moon disappear from the sky means she could predict the time and general area where a lunar eclipse would occur.

Lunar eclipses have been observed and recorded for centuries, and they continue to captivate sky watchers around the world. Beyond their astronomical significance, lunar eclipses have also played cultural and symbolic roles in various societies throughout history.

A lunar eclipse occurs when the Earth comes between the Sun and the Moon, causing the Earth’s shadow to be cast upon the Moon. This celestial alignment results in a temporary dimming or darkening of the lunar surface, creating a visually striking astronomical event. Unlike a solar eclipse, which involves the Moon passing between the Earth and the Sun, a lunar eclipse is visible from anywhere on the nighttime side of the Earth where the Moon is above the horizon.

Many female astrologers, often regarded as sorcerers, were associated with Aglaonice. They were known as the “Witches of Thessaly” and were active from the 1st to 3rd centuries BC. The word “Witch” is an epithet given to them by later authors, although it is likely that Aglaonice was regarded as a sorceress by her contemporaries. 

In Plato’s Gorgias (circa 380 BCE), Socrates speaks of “the Thessalian enchantresses, who, as they say, bring down the moon from heaven at the risk of their perdition.” Plutarch wrote that she was “thoroughly acquainted with the periods of the full moon when it is subject to eclipse, and, knowing beforehand the time when the moon was due to be overtaken by the earth’s shadow, imposed upon the women, and made them all believe that she was drawing down the moon.” Aglaonice is the name of one of the craters of the planet Venus.

The name “Aglaonice” is a character in the Jean Cocteau movie Orpheus, where she is a friend of Eurydice and leader of the “League of Women.” Aglaonice is a featured figure in Judy Chicago’s installation piece. A Greek proverb refers to Aglaonice’s alleged boasting: “Yes, as the moon obeys Aglaonice.”

She can be regarded as one of the early women in astronomy because she had mastered the art of predicting eclipses. This ability to forecast a lunar eclipse would be possible for anyone of that time who was familiar with the full moon’s periods and eclipses’ cycles. The superstitions of the time allowed a person with such knowledge to control people through their fear of the unknown.

The Hellenistic expansion and the intellectual awakening that followed the Classical period marked Aglaonice’s era. Against societal norms that restricted women’s access to education and scientific pursuits in those days, Aglaonice’s journey into astronomy became all the more remarkable. Little is known about her early life, but her emergence as a prominent figure in the field speaks volumes about her passion and dedication to studying the heavens.

While the details of her methods are lost to time, it is evident that she possessed a keen observational acumen and likely engaged in mathematical calculations to forecast these celestial events. With their predictable patterns and recurring cycles, lunar eclipses provided a canvas upon which Aglaonice could display her astronomical prowess.

With its rich tapestry of myth and science, the ancient Greek world often intertwined astronomy with divine narratives. Aglaonice’s work was situated within this cultural context. Her ability to predict lunar eclipses might have been perceived as mystical foresight. When understood and predicted, the celestial dance of the moon and the sun could be a source of great awe and reverence.

Aglaonice’s contributions to astronomy also shed light on the collaborative nature of scientific inquiry in the ancient world. She was part of a community of scholars who shared knowledge and observations, engaging in dialogues that fueled intellectual curiosity. While her name may be one of the few that survived the passage of time, Aglaonice was likely part of a broader network of thinkers who collectively expanded the frontiers of ancient astronomy.

As with many historical figures, legend and myth are intertwined with Aglaonice’s story. The accounts suggesting that she possessed the power to draw down the moon from the sky, added the mystical layer to her persona. The tales underscore the impact Aglaonice had on the collective imagination of her contemporaries.

Aglaonice is slowly being resurrected from the obscurity of historical oversight as historians and scholars delve into the remnants of ancient records in the modern era. Pursuing knowledge has no limits, and she serves as a reminder. Even in antiquity, women such as Aglaonice sought to unravel the mysteries of the cosmos.

Aglaonice’s legacy echoes through the corridors of time, inviting us to reflect on the enduring spirit of inquiry that transcends cultural and temporal boundaries. Her contributions to predicting lunar eclipses may be modest by today’s scientific standards. In the context of her era however, they represented a pioneering venture into the uncharted territories of the night sky.

Aglaonice, the ancient astronomer, invites us to look beyond the stars and glimpse the indomitable light that emanates from the minds of those who dared to explore the cosmos.

Aglaonice is now a welcome addition to our ECG Hall of Fame Library.

Sources:

Wikipedia

Scientific Women. History of Scientific Women. Aglaonice

Quantum Communication with Extraterrestrials. Time to Revise the Current Experiment

Extraterrestrial (ET) communication is a subject that is fascinating to me. I have done a lot of research and composed several articles on the subject. Our historic attempts to send or receive a message from the cosmos have failed. Unless, of course, there is a giant government cover-up and conspiracy going on. A plot intended to keep the public in the dark on the matter.

The agencies charged with seeking that ET signal have been unable to follow the basic principles of the scientific method. They have had no success, yet they continue to do the same thing in the same way. They do it in the same way, hoping for a different result. Those are strong words from a guy not in the game at a professional level; however, it is a valid “hypothesis.”

The scientific method is a beacon illuminating the path of inquiry, discovery, and understanding in science. It is a systematic approach. It is a structured process that empowers scientists to unravel the natural world’s mysteries. Driven by empirical evidence and logical reasoning, the scientific method is a dynamic and iterative process that has fueled centuries of scientific progress.

The journey of discovery begins with a hypothesis based on imperial observation – a keen, curious gaze cast upon the world. Scientists, driven by an insatiable curiosity, observe natural phenomena, ask questions, and identify areas of interest. This initial step sets the stage for the scientific process, prompting the formulation of hypotheses and the framing of research questions.

Hypotheses emerge as tentative explanations for observed phenomena. These are educated guesses, informed by existing knowledge and guided by a desire to test and validate assumptions. Well-crafted hypotheses serve as the foundation for the subsequent stages of experimentation and analysis. The ET communication process has been established in part.

The heart of the scientific method beats in the laboratory or field where experimentation occurs. Rigorous investigation involves the manipulation of variables to test hypotheses. Scientists gather evidence supporting or refuting their initial assumptions through meticulous data collection. The reliability and validity of data are paramount, requiring precision and attention to detail. This part of the process in our search for an ET message has been going on for decades. It is going on at great expense with no results.

Data, the currency of scientific inquiry, undergo analysis to extract meaningful patterns and trends. Statistical methods and mathematical models help scientists discern the significance of their findings. The interpretation phase involves:

      • Connecting the dots.
      • Drawing conclusions based on empirical evidence.
      • Refining the understanding of the phenomena under investigation.

Data collection is the part of the ET communication experiment that has failed. The only data is that there is no data.

The process culminates in drawing conclusions that contribute to scientific knowledge. Most importantly, the scientific community is engaged in a continuous dialogue through peer review. Fellow scientists scrutinize, critique, and validate the experiment. Peer review acts as a quality control mechanism, upholding the standards of scientific inquiry.

The way I see it, concerning the ET communication experiment, there are two possibilities to consider. The first is that the investigation has proven that we are alone in the universe. The second is we are trying to communicate the wrong way. It is highly unlikely that that humans are the only intelligent life in the cosmos. Therefore, scientists must revise the experiment. 

Scientific knowledge is a dynamic that is subject to refinement and revision. The scientific method embraces the notion that understanding evolves with each process iteration. If new evidence is exposed, scientists must adapt their theories and hypotheses, perpetuating a continuous improvement cycle.

The scientific endeavor extends beyond the laboratory bench. Effective communication of findings through research papers, conferences, and publications is essential. Equally important is the concept of replication and the ability of other researchers to reproduce experiments and validate results independently. Replication reinforces the reliability of scientific discoveries and guards against anomalies or errors.  

While the scientific method is rigorous and objective, creativity and imagination are integral components. The formulation of hypotheses often requires creative insight, and the design of experiments demands innovative thinking. The interplay between structured methodology and creative exploration fuels the engine of scientific discovery.

The scientific method is not merely a set of procedural steps. The scientific method is a philosophy, a mindset that embraces skepticism, evidence-based reasoning, and a commitment to the pursuit of truth.

From the microscopic realm of subatomic particles to the cosmic expanses of the universe, the scientific method is humanity’s most potent tool for unraveling the intricacies of the natural world and expanding the frontiers of knowledge. It is a timeless guide, leading generations of curious minds on a quest for understanding and enlightenment.

I have published a book entitled Extraterrestrial Communication Code. The book ultimately develops a hypothesis about ET Communication based on observations. The theory is that ET communication efforts, using the same tools, need to identify a time and place from where to listen and send our ones and zeros messages.

What my book should have also considered is something called Quantum Communication. Quantum communication is a genuine and actively researched field within quantum information science. It harnesses the principles of quantum mechanics to enable secure and efficient communication between parties. Quantum mechanics is a fundamental branch of physics that deals with the behavior of matter and energy on minor scales, typically at the level of atoms and subatomic particles. It provides a mathematical framework to understand and predict the behavior of particles at the quantum level, where classical physics concepts break down. 

I will tell you that Quantum anything is complicated, and I do not pretend to be an expert or even a novice on how it all works. I aim to offer my readers the basics on how this could be a significant link to successfully establishing ET communication in our lifetime. Quantum Communication may be the adjustment to our current ET communication experiment that the scientific method demands. Scientists have achieved quantum communication. Several groundbreaking experiments and demonstrations have showcased the principles of quantum communication.

Humanity continues to turn its eyes and ears toward the stars with the prospect of communicating with extraterrestrial civilizations. The conventional means of communication, grounded in classical information theory, have proven inadequate for bridging the vast cosmic distances that separate us from potential extraterrestrial beings. Enter quantum communication, a revolutionary approach grounded in quantum mechanics principles, with the promise of transcending classical limits and establishing a cosmic dialogue with intelligence beyond our celestial borders.

At the heart of quantum communication with extraterrestrials lies the extraordinary entanglement phenomenon. Despite its mysterious and non-intuitive nature, quantum entanglement has been experimentally verified in various setups, and it remains one of the most intriguing aspects of quantum mechanics.

Quantum Communication continues to be a topic of research and exploration for its potential applications in quantum technologies and its implications for our understanding of the fundamental nature of reality.

If extraterrestrial civilizations harness quantum mechanics, this entanglement could serve as a cosmic bond, allowing instantaneous communication regardless of the immense distances that separate celestial bodies. Changes in the quantum state of particles entangled across cosmic expanses could convey messages faster than the speed of light, challenging the constraints imposed by classical communication.

In secure communication, quantum key distribution (QKD) emerges as a beacon of hope for ensuring the confidentiality of messages exchanged with extraterrestrial intelligence. The principles of QKD could enable the establishment of secure cryptographic keys, immune to eavesdropping even across the cosmic void. The secrecy of quantum keys, based on the fundamental principles of quantum mechanics, offers a level of security that classical cryptographic systems cannot match.

As cosmic distances present formidable challenges to preserving quantum information, the concept of quantum repeaters takes center stage. Quantum repeaters, akin to celestial relay stations, could extend the range of quantum communication systems, enabling the faithful transmission of quantum states over interstellar distances.

Overcoming the cosmic decoherence that threatens the integrity of quantum information becomes a pivotal step in establishing a robust quantum communication infrastructure with extraterrestrial civilizations.

The compelling concept of quantum teleportation enters the realm of cosmic communication. While not involving the physical movement of matter, quantum teleportation allows the transmission of quantum information between distant locations. Imagining a scenario where extraterrestrial civilizations employ quantum teleportation to exchange information across cosmic expanses opens avenues for instantaneous cosmic communication and collaboration.

In the quest for establishing a shared language with extraterrestrial intelligences, universal quantum languages, and mathematical constants emerge as potential communication mediums. Concepts like prime numbers or fundamental physical constants, rooted in the universality of mathematics, could serve as a cosmic Rosetta Stone by transcending linguistic and cultural barriers in our attempts to decipher extraterrestrial messages.

Envisioning a cosmic community of intelligent civilizations interconnected through quantum networks adds a layer of complexity to the dialogue. Quantum networks, linking diverse celestial entities, could facilitate the exchange of quantum information, knowledge, and cultural insights. The interplay of entangled particles across cosmic scales transforms the cosmos into a vast, interconnected quantum tapestry.

The fusion of quantum mechanics and cosmic exploration sparks the imagination in the speculative realm of quantum communication with extraterrestrials. While the technical and theoretical challenges are monumental, the allure of a heavenly dialogue conducted through the language of quantum physics propels us into uncharted territories.

As humanity contemplates its place in the cosmos, the vision of communicating with extraterrestrial intelligence through the wonders of quantum communication adds a profound and awe-inspiring dimension to our cosmic aspirations.

The journey towards understanding and connecting with other intelligent beings may well be guided by the principles of quantum mechanics, offering a heavenly bridge that transcends the limitations of classical communication methods.

It is time to recognize that our historic attempts at ET communication have failed. It is time to follow the scientific method and revise the experiment.

Sources:

Wikipedia / Britannica / Science News / Nature / The Institute of Engineering & Technology

Science Education Pioneer Guillermo Gonzalez

Guillermo Gonzalez is a prominent astrophysicist known for his contributions to astronomy and his work searching for extraterrestrial intelligence (SETI). Gonzalez was born on February 19, 1963, in Havana, Cuba. Academic excellence, research achievements, and engagement in broader scientific discussions have marked his career in astrophysics.

Guillermo Gonzalez (AP Photo/Nirmalendu Majumdar, File)

His family sparked his passion for the cosmos at an early age. They immigrated to the United States from Cuba when he was young, and this transition provided him with opportunities to pursue his scientific interests. Gonzalez earned his bachelor’s degree in physics and astronomy from the University of Arizona in 1987. His academic journey continued as he pursued a Ph.D. in astronomy from the University of Washington, which he completed in 1993.

Both research and teaching characterize his dedication. He held positions at various esteemed institutions, including the University of Washington, the University of Texas, Austin, and Iowa State University, where he served as an Assistant Professor of Physics and Astronomy.

One of Gonzalez’s significant contributions to astronomy is his research on the Galactic Habitable Zone. This concept posits that the location within a galaxy significantly influences a star system’s ability to support complex life. Gonzalez’s work in this area sheds light on the factors that contribute to a star’s habitability, considering aspects such as metallicity, radiation, and stable orbits.

In collaboration with Jay W. Richards, Gonzalez co-authored the book “The Privileged Planet: How Our Place in the Cosmos is Designed for Discovery.” The book explores the idea that Earth is habitable and uniquely positioned to allow for scientific discovery. It delves into the relationship between habitability and the ability to observe and comprehend the universe, presenting a thought-provoking perspective on the intersection of science and philosophy.

Gonzalez regularly contributed to Facts for Faith magazine, produced by Reasons To Believe, an old earth creationist group. Reasons to Believe is a nonprofit organization that promotes day-age forms of old Earth creationism. It was founded in 1986 by Hugh Ross, a Canadian-born astrophysicist and creationist Christian apologist. 

Christian apologetics is a branch of Christian theology that defends Christianity. It is a topic of theology has taken many forms over the centuries. It started with Paul the Apostle in the early church and included Patristic writers such as OrigenAugustine of HippoJustin Martyr, and Tertullian. Christian Apologetics continued with writers such as Thomas AquinasDuns ScotusWilliam of Ockham, and Anselm of Canterbury during Scholasticism.

Blaise Pascal was an active Christian apologist during the 17th century. In the modern period, the efforts of many authors defended Christianity. Some of these authors included John Henry NewmanG. K. ChestertonC. S. Lewis, and G. E. M. Anscombe.

 In the first century CE, according to Edgar J. Goodspeed, Jewish apologetic elements could be seen in works such as The Wisdom of SolomonPhilo’s On the Contemplative Life, and more explicitly in Josephus’ Against Apion.

Christian apologetics first appears in the New Testament (e.g., Paul’s preaching on Mars Hill in Acts 17:22-31). During the subapostolic age, Christianity already competed with Judaism and other religions and sects in the Greco-Roman world. Christian apologetics can be first seen in the “Preaching of Peter” (Gospel of Peter). The first explicitly apologetic work however, comes from Quadratus of Athens (c. 125 CE). In it he writes a defense of the faith to emperor Hadrian. Only a fragment, quoted by Eusebius, has survived to our day:

“But the works of our Saviour were always present, for they were genuine: those that were healed, and those that were raised from the dead, who were seen not only when they were healed and when they were raised, but were also always present; and not merely while the Saviour was on earth, but also after his death, they were alive for quite a while, so that some of them lived even to our day” (Church History iv. 3. 2)

In addition to Guillermo Gonzalez’s work for the Discovery Institute and the International Society for Complexity, Information, and Design, he is a researcher for the Biologic Institute, funded by the Institute for Research into Intelligent Design.

Guillermo Gonzalez became embroiled in controversies about his support for the theory of Intelligent Design (ID).

ID proposes that certain features of the universe and living organisms are best explained by an intelligent cause rather than an undirected process such as natural selection. Gonzalez’s advocacy for ID led to tensions within the academic community, and his tenure at Iowa State University was not renewed in 2007, a decision that sparked debates about academic freedom.

His stance on that issue and unwillingness to yield is a testament to the protection of critical thinking in education. He would not yield to the University’s closed-minded policy on the matter. He refused to be indoctrinated and pass that indoctrination policy on to his students. The world today needs more courageous teachers like Gonzales.

Gonzalez’s legacy extends beyond his specific research contributions. His work on the Galactic Habitable Zone has influenced discussions about the conditions necessary for life in the universe. While controversies surround his involvement in the Intelligent Design movement, Gonzalez remains an influential figure in astronomy.

Guillermo Gonzalez’s work as an astronomer encompasses significant contributions to our understanding of habitability in the cosmos. His research, teaching, and engagement with broader scientific and philosophical discussions have left an indelible mark on astronomy. 

Despite the controversies surrounding his advocacy for Intelligent Design, Gonzalez’s work continues to be a subject of scholarly discussion and debate.

 

The Extraterrestrial Communication Group welcomes Guillermo Gonzalez to our Hall of Fame Library.

Sources:

Wikipedia / Britannica / Discovery Institute

A Trailblazing Woman of Astronomy: Maria Mitchell: A

Maria Mitchell (1818-1889): A Trailblazing Astronomer

Maria Mitchell, an American astronomer born in 1818, is a pioneering figure in the history of astronomy. Her life and career were marked by a deep passion for the stars. She had an unyielding commitment to education, and a determination to break down social and gender barriers.

Maria Mitchell was born in Nantucket, Massachusetts, and was raised in an environment that encouraged intellectual curiosity and a love for learning. Maria Mitchell’s father was William Mitchell.

He was a dedicated amateur astronomer and a teacher who played a significant role in nurturing his daughter’s interest in astronomy and education. William Mitchell’s own passion for astronomy and his encouragement of Maria’s intellectual pursuits had a profound influence on her development as a scientist. Mitchell’s education was diverse and included exposure to mathematics, science, and the humanities. Her early education set the stage for her future endeavors.

One of Maria Mitchell’s most significant scientific achievements was the discovery of a new comet on October 1, 1847. This discovery, known as “Miss Mitchell’s Comet,” brought her international recognition. It made her the first American woman and the third woman in the world to discover a comet.

The fame she gained from this discovery was not only a testament to her observational skills but also a powerful assertion of women’s capabilities in the sciences.

Her primary instrument was a 5-inch aperture refracting telescope. This telescope, known as the “Great Refractor,” was made by the prominent American telescope manufacturer Henry Fitz, who was known for producing high-quality telescopes during the 19th century. The Great Refractor was installed at the Nantucket Atheneum library on Nantucket Island, Massachusetts. The Nantucket Atheneum was founded in 1834. It is one of the oldest public libraries in the United States. It was established by a group of Nantucket residents who shared a commitment to fostering education and intellectual pursuits. The telescope was placed in a dome on the rooftop of the Atheneum.

Mitchell used this telescope to make her historic comet discovery on October 1, 1847. The telescope’s quality and precision were instrumental in her ability to observe and document celestial objects.

In addition to her comet discovery, Maria Mitchell’s work in astronomy extended to pioneering photography as a tool for astronomical observations. She was one of the first astronomers to employ photography for capturing images of the stars. Mitchell also built her own telescopes and other astronomical instruments, exhibiting her versatility as a scientist and astronomer.

Mitchell’s dedication to studying celestial objects led her to compile extensive catalogs of stars, including their positions and characteristics. Her diligent work cataloging star positions was critical for navigation and astronomy. Mitchell’s work earned her a place at the American Nautical Almanac Office, where she contributed to the computation of navigational tables.

Beyond her groundbreaking scientific contributions, Maria Mitchell advocated for education, especially for women.

She believed that education should be accessible to all and fought for equal educational opportunities regardless of gender. Her teaching career at Vassar College, where she was the first woman appointed to a professorship in astronomy, was marked by her commitment to fostering young women’s interest in science.

Maria Mitchell’s legacy extends beyond her time as her groundbreaking achievements inspire and empower future female scientists and astronomers. Her life’s work served as a potent reminder that women could excel in fields traditionally dominated by men. She defied societal norms and paved the way for women in science, leaving an enduring mark on the history of astronomy and the broader scientific community.

In 1841, Mitchell attended the anti-slavery convention in Nantucket where Frederick Douglass made his first speech, and she also became involved in the anti-slavery movement by boycotting clothes made of Southern cotton. She later became involved in a number of social issues as a professor, particularly those pertaining to women’s suffrage and education. 

She also befriended various suffragists including Elizabeth Cady Stanton. After returning from a trip to Europe in 1873, Mitchell joined the national women’s movement and helped found the Association for the Advancement of Women (AAW), a group dedicated to educational reform and the promotion of women in higher education. Mitchell addressed the Association’s First Women’s Congress in a speech titled The Higher Education of Women in which she described the work of English women working for access to higher education at Girton College, Cambridge.

“The laws of Nature are not discovered by accident; theories do not come by chance, even to the greatest minds; they are not born of the hurry and worry of daily toil; they are diligently sought, they are patiently waited for, they are received with cautious reserve, they are accepted with reverence and awe. And until able women have given their lives to investigation, it is idle to discuss the question of their capacity for original work.”

Mitchell advocated for women working part-time while acquiring their education to not only ease the wages off of men paying for their education, but also to empower more women to be in the workforce. She also called attention to the place for women in science and mathematics and encouraged others to support women’s colleges and women’s campaigns to serve on local school boards. Mitchell served as the second president of the AAW in 1875 and 1876 before stepping down to head a special Committee on Science to analyze and promote women’s progress in the field. She held this position until her death in 1889.

Maria Mitchell’s telescope is on display in the Smithsonian Institution National Museum of American History.

 

Mitchell died of brain disease on June 28, 1889, in Lynn, Massachusetts at the age of 70. She was buried in Lot 411, in Prospect Hill Cemetery, Nantucket. The Maria Mitchell Association was established to promote the sciences on Nantucket and preserve the legacy Mitchell’s work. The Association operates a Natural History Museum, an Aquarium, a Science Library and Research Center, Maria Mitchell’s Home Museum, and an Observatory named in her honor, the Maria Mitchell Observatory.

In 1989, Mitchell was named a National Women’s History Month Honoree by the National Women’s History Project and was inducted into the National Women’s Hall of Fame in 1994. She was the namesake of a World War II Liberty ship, the SS Maria Mitchell, and New York’s Metro North commuter railroad (with its Hudson Line endpoint in Poughkeepsie near Vassar College) has a train named the Maria Mitchell Comet. A crater on the Moon was also named in her honor.   

Her unique place at the intersection of American science and culture has been captured in a number of publications. During her life, Mitchell published seven items in the Royal Society Catalog and three articles detailing her observations in Silliman’s Journal. Mitchell also authored three articles for Hours at HomeCentury, and The Atlantic.

Her story serves as an inspiration for all those who strive to overcome obstacles and make meaningful contributions to the advancement of human understanding.

“The progress of the intellect is to the clearer vision of causes, which neglects surface differences. To the poet, to the philosopher, to the saint, all things are friendly and sacred, all events profitable, all days holy, all men divine.”– Maria Mitchell

Maria Michel’s story is now a well deserving member of the Extraterrestrial Communication Group Hall of Fame Library

Sources:

Wikipedia

Britannica

Womans Natural History Museum: Maria Mitchell

Science, Faith and Education in America

I am trying to understand all of the increasing violence and twisted social, political, and ethical issues burning in virtually every country of the world today. Why is it happening? How do we fix it?

Rockets are still aimed at people to this day despite the lessons of history. How is it possible that one group of people can have such hate for another that they will raid their homes and brutalize women and children? What drives a man to chop off the head of a baby and feel as though he is doing the right thing?

How is it possible that gender identity issues and sexuality are being brought into public grade schools and put before children who still believe in the tooth fairy, the Easter Bunny, and Santa Claus? It seems like either pure evil or pure insanity or possibly both.

I believe that the root cause lies within a diminished educational balance that includes science and religion. Education is the cornerstone of progress, and the curriculum shapes the minds of future generations.

The following is my opinion on the matter based on some research of the underlying facts. 

Over recent years, there has been a documented trend away from science education in many educational systems in America and worldwide. One of the most profound challenges facing contemporary education systems is this shift away from science education. This decline in science education in American institutions is proving to be trend of critical concern.  

Excited girls using chemistry set together in elementary science classroom

Restoring science education to its rightful place in the curriculum ensures that future generations possess the knowledge and critical thinking skills required. This knowledge is necessary for a society that relies on science and technology for progress and innovation. Balancing the curriculum, improving teacher training, and depoliticizing science education are critical steps. Steps in a process to address these concerns and strengthen science education worldwide.  

Several factors contribute to this shift away from an education that includes a strong science component:

Education systems, especially in the United States, often prioritize subjects directly assessed in standardized tests.

Science, particularly in early education, receives less emphasis as it is not a primary focus of standardized assessments.

Schools need more money. Lack of funding results in fewer science courses, outdated equipment, and insufficient opportunities for hands-on learning.

Educators need more training to teach science effectively. More qualified teachers can make it easier for students to engage with scientific concepts.

Parents play a critical role in shaping the educational experiences of their children.

If parents have limited understanding or appreciation for science, they tend to not prioritize it in their children’s education. It has become a generational issue. 

The shift away from science education has several implications:

A reduced emphasis on science in education results in a less scientifically literate society. This reduced emphasis limits individuals’ ability to understand and engage with significant scientific and technological developments. In an increasingly complex and technology-driven world, scientific literacy is crucial for informed decision-making and active citizenship.

Scientific knowledge and critical thinking skills are essential for innovation. A weaker emphasis on science hinders our nation’s ability to compete globally and advance technologically. Science education fosters innovation and entrepreneurship, contributing to economic growth and development.

A lack of science education leads to insufficient understanding of critical issues such as climate change, health, and other environmental concerns. This lack of knowledge can have long-term consequences. Many of the world’s most pressing challenges, such as climate change and pandemics, require a scientifically informed public and a skilled workforce to address them.

Most children are naturally curious about the world. Science education helps nurture that curiosity. A reduced emphasis on science education stifles this innate desire to explore and understand. Science education encourages critical thinking, problem-solving, and interest. All are valuable components of personal and intellectual development.

Education plays a pivotal role in shaping the perspectives and values of future generations. In recent years, there has been increased attention to the influence of a left-wing agenda in educational institutions. The left-wing political agenda is often championed for its emphasis on social justice, government intervention, and equality. It has gained prominence in many countries, particularly in America. 

The rise of the left-wing agenda in educational institutions is a complex and controversial issue. It raises crucial questions about ideological diversity, academic freedom, and the role of education in society.

The left-wing educational agenda has grown into an educational monster that has crossed over the line from inappropriate indoctrination into the land of brainwashing young minds for the sole purpose of promoting a very scary social agenda.

Often times these kids don’t seem to truly know what they are saying and doing or why they are saying and doing it. They are just repeating the words of others without question. It is a terrifying situation we live within our world today.  

The left-wing political agenda raises significant concerns about the balance between government intervention and individual freedom, economic implications, and the preservation of cultural and traditional values. The left-wing agenda seeks to address social and economic challenges. Its critics contend that its approach does not strike the right balance between promoting equality and respecting personal liberties.

Engaging in open dialogue and constructive debate between different political perspectives is crucial for finding solutions that address the complex issues facing our societies today.

Critics argue that left wing curriculum, particularly in the humanities and social sciences, tends to emphasize left-leaning ideologies, such as social justice, identity politics, and critical race theory. It does this while marginalizing or neglecting conservative viewpoints.

Concerns about the political leanings of faculty and staff are raised. There is a left-leaning dominance and the lack of conservative representation within higher education.

There is a growing atmosphere of political correctness, safe spaces, and trigger warnings, which are directly linked to the stifling of free speech and promoting a progressive ideological echo chamber.

The left-wing agenda in educational institutions has raised several concerns. A lack of political diversity among faculty and staff can lead to a one-sided presentation of ideas and hinder constructive debate.

Promoting particular values may undermine the educational mission of fostering critical thinking and independent inquiry. (AKA Indoctrination).

Conservative students often feel marginalized or hesitant to express their viewpoints, fearing backlash or negative consequences.

The educational results we are seeing and living with in today’s world demonstrate the need for ideological diversity, academic freedom, and the role of education in society. To address these concerns, educational institutions must foster open dialogue, encourage a balanced representation of ideas, and reaffirm their commitment to critical thinking, intellectual diversity, and academic freedom. 

There is a religious component to this discussion to consider as well. There is a direct correlation between the removal of religious education for younger students and the decline in social and moral behavior as these children move into adulthood.

The role of religion in grade school education has long been a subject of debate. As societies become more diverse and secular, there has been an increasing call for the removal of religion from grade school education. This exclusion is a substantial component of the root-cause analysis to identify the causes of moral decay in modern society.

One of the primary arguments for removing religion from grade school education is the promotion of secularism and inclusivity. The idea is that public education should be neutral and free from religious bias. This neutrality ensures that all students, regardless of their faith or lack thereof, feel welcome and respected.

Critics of religious education in any public school, express concerns about the potential for religious indoctrination. They argue that exposing young and impressionable minds to spiritual teachings may lead to the undue influence of one particular faith or belief system. In increasingly diverse societies, there is recognition of the wide range of religious and non-religious beliefs. Removing religious content from the curriculum helps avoid favoring one religion over another and respects the pluralistic nature of modern communities. 

Advocates for the removal of religion from grade school education emphasize parental rights. They argue that parents should be primarily responsible for teaching their children about their religious beliefs, and the state should not infringe on this right. All of that can appear logical at face value; however, there is much more to it than that. It is strange and disturbing to me that these same people hypocritically believe it is proper for public schools to teach sexual identity and gender topics to these very young children. Even worse – to do it or try to do it without parental knowledge. It’s just not right in my mind and in my opinion. It is a root cause to the bigger problem we are talking about. 

Religion has played a significant role in shaping the culture and history of many societies. Critics argue that understanding the religious foundations of art, literature, history, and community is essential for a well-rounded education. Religion often provides a framework for moral and ethical education. It teaches values such as compassion, empathy, and respect for others. These teachings can have a positive impact on character development.

Teaching about religion (rather than religious instruction) makes it possible to teach students about different religious beliefs without promoting one over the others. This educational approach fosters tolerance and understanding. Teaching about religion offers educational value by exploring its influence on art, history, literature, and culture. Learning about religious beliefs and practices is academically enriching and contributes to a well-rounded education.

The debate over the removal of religion from grade school education is a complex one. It requires a careful balance between promoting secularism, respecting religious diversity, and recognizing the educational value of spiritual knowledge. A possible compromise involves teaching about religion in an objective, inclusive, and non-indoctrinating manner.

This can be achieved while at the same time, ensuring that parents’ rights are respected and honored, and the educational environment remains inclusive and respectful of all students. It is a mistake for the educators of our young children to think they should exclude parents from the development and teaching of a curriculum for their children.  

The removal of religion from grade school education has clearly had an enormous impact on the moral decay of society on a global scale, especially in America. Religious freedom played a significant role in the founding of America.

We have forgotten (or not taught at a young age) that religious freedom is the backbone of the American experiment. The early European settlers who came to the American colonies sought religious freedom and refuge from religious persecution in their home countries.

For example, the Pilgrims, who arrived on the Mayflower in 1620, sought religious freedom and the ability to practice their form of Protestant Christianity without persecution. Similarly, the Puritans who settled in the Massachusetts Bay Colony in the early 17th century were motivated by religious reasons. Maryland was a refuge for Catholics, and Pennsylvania was settled by Quakers who sought a place to practice their faith without interference.

The importance of religious freedom is enshrined in the First Amendment to the United States Constitution, which states:

“Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.” 

The First Amendment reflects the Founding Fathers’ commitment to ensuring that individuals in the newly formed United States were free to practice their religion or no religion without fear of persecution. While the American colonies were settled for various reasons, including economic and political ones, pursuing religious freedom was undoubtedly a significant driving force in the founding of the United States.

Striking an educational balance that respects the rights and beliefs of all students while recognizing the educational value of religious knowledge is essential. In this ongoing debate, it is crucial to engage in open dialogue and thoughtful consideration to find the most appropriate and inclusive approach to religious education in an increasingly diverse and secular world.

A well-rounded education should expose students to various perspectives, allowing them to think critically and make informed decisions as they navigate an increasingly complex world.

The shift away from science education is a trend that has important implications for society, education, and individual growth. There is an urgent need to reemphasize the importance of science education backed by an understanding of world religions. This focus will prepare future generations to navigate a rapidly changing world. Receiving this sort of education, I suspect that the moral issues of modern society will improve organically.

As Benjamin Franklin, one of our Founding Fathers, once stated:

“Take care of the pence, and the pounds will care for themselves.”

It is a statement something that I see as applicable to education. Take care of the building blocks of science and religious education (the pence) and a society’s morality (the pounds) will take care of itself by default. 

Achieving this requires proper funding, resources, teacher training, and a shift in societal attitudes toward science and faith in our educational system. By doing so, we can ensure that science and religion remain at the forefront of education, fostering a more scientifically literate, innovative, and engaged society.

I invite you to visit the ECG’s Library to find and enjoy additional articles and news about the historic people of Science, current events and posts about the cosmos and our place within it. 

Sources:

  1. National Science Foundation (NSF) Website
  2. “Science Education in the United States: An Analysis of Policy and Practice” by the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine
  3. “Religion in the Public Schools” by the National Center for Science Education (NCSE)
  4. “Social Impact of Progressive Policies” by the Center for American Progress
  5. “The Ideological Origins of the American Revolution” by Bernard Bailyn

 

Anaximander of Miletus: An Ancient Philosopher and Astronomer of “Boundless” Thinking

You might be familiar with the works of Aristotle, Socrates, and Plato due to their contributions as early Greek scholars. Have you ever heard about Anaximander, the first philosopher to make massive changes to the astronomical world and natural philosophy?

He was a pre-Socratic philosopher, predating the typical study of Greek scholars. That’s probably why you never heard of him.

When studying ancient Greek thinkers, it is natural to place them in specific categories including philosopher, astronomer, biologist, or physician. Two thousand years ago these distinctions didn’t exist. The great minds of the ancient world seldom limited themselves to a specific topic of study, as we do today. For them, there was no distinction between what we now call “science” and “philosophy.”

The line between science and philosophy can often be a blurred one. The difference is that science depends on observations and experimentation, and it produces a “result,” whereas philosophy depends on logical arguments and doesn’t necessarily have to produce a “result.”

Anaximander of Miletus, a thinker of the pre-Socratic era, is a remarkable figure in the history of philosophy and astronomy. Living around 610-546 BCE in the ancient Greek city of Miletus, Anaximander made profound contributions to cosmology, biology, and metaphysics.

His philosophical ideas laid the foundation for a more rational and systematic approach to understanding the natural world, marking a significant shift from mythological explanations to early scientific thought.

In the 2017 essay collection Anaximander in Context: New Studies on the Origins of Greek Philosophy, Dirk Couprie, Robert Hahn, and Gerald Naddaf describe Anaximander’s mind as “one of the greatest minds in history.” Couprie goes on to state that he considers him on par with Newton.

Anaximander is the first scholar to write a book on Natural Philosophy, which paved the path for many contemporary philosophers. His book “On Nature” argued for the concept of the Aperion. 

The apeiron concept is his most enduring contribution to philosophy. He postulated that an underlying, boundless, and indefinite principle was the source of all things. According to Aristotle and Theophrastus, the first Greek philosophers were looking for the “origin” or “principle” (the Greek word “archê” has both meanings) of all things. Anaximander identified it with “the Boundless” or “the Unlimited” (Greek: “Apeiron,” that is, “that which has no boundaries”).

“Everything has an origin or is an origin. The Boundless has no origin. For then, it would have a limit. Moreover, it is both unborn and immortal, a kind of origin. For that which has become has also, necessarily, an end, and there is a termination to every process of destruction”.

Most of this book is unidentified as the fragments are lost in time. A primary source is his successor, Theophrastus, who referenced some parts of “On Nature” and was a follower of Anaximander’s accounts of Geography, Biology, and Astronomy.

Anaximander never fully or clearly explained explain what he meant by “the Boundless.” More recently, authors have disputed whether the Boundless should be interpreted spatially or temporarily without limits, perhaps as that which has no qualifications or as inexhaustible. Some scholars have even defended the meaning as:

“That which is not experienced” by relating the Greek word “Apeiron” not to “peras” (“boundary,” “limit”) but to “perao” (“to experience,” “to apperceive”).

The Greeks in those days were familiar with the idea of the immortal Homeric gods. Anaximander added two distinctive features to the concept of divinity:

        • Boundless is an impersonal something, and
        • Boundless is not only immortal but also unborn.

“All the heavens and the worlds within them” have sprung from “some boundless nature.”

This concept directly challenged prevailing mythological explanations for the origins of the cosmos.

Anaximander’s life and background are essential for understanding his philosophical contributions. Born in Miletus, a thriving city of Ionia, he was a contemporary of Thales, another prominent pre-Socratic philosopher. His background likely included exposure to the cosmopolitan culture of Ionia and its connection to the broader Mediterranean world. 

Anaximander is credited as the first Greek geographer to attempt the map of our world, at least according to ancient observers. It was not unusual to use regional maps in the olden times. However, the thought of mapping out the whole globe was much more novel. Only after Anaximander started this endeavor, Hecataeus of Miletus, who was a traveler, attempted making the perfect map out of his predecessor’s creation while improving on it. 

He did not restrict his thinking to astronomy and geography. Anaximander extended his philosophical inquiries into the realm of biology. He theorized about evolution, concluding that life first arose in wet rather than dry conditions.  He sought to explain the origins and development of life, suggesting that humans and animals evolved from simpler forms. His ideas were among the earliest precursors to the theory of evolution.

Anaximander developed a unique cosmological model that challenged traditional beliefs about the Earth’s centrality in the cosmos.

He proposed a universe where the Earth was not at the center but a celestial body in its own right. Three propositions, which make up the core of Anaximander’s astronomy, are a tremendous jump forward and constitute the origin of our Western concept of the universe. His astronomical speculations are as follows:

Celestial bodies make full circles and pass beneath the Earth.
The Earth floats free and unsupported in space.
The celestial bodies lie behind one another.

The idea that the celestial bodies, in their daily course, make complete circles and thus pass beneath the Earth – from Anaximander’s viewpoint – is so self-evident to us that it is hard to understand how daring its introduction was.

That the celestial bodies make full circles is not something he could have observed but a conclusion he must have drawn. 

 

 

His cosmological ideas laid the foundation for future astronomers and philosophers to explore the universe’s structure.

Among many of his other inventions, Anaximander was also responsible for introducing the gnomon and sundial into Greek culture. He traveled to Sparta to set up a gnomon, a simple pillar that is fixed straight over markings on the ground, representing a dial. Based on the shadows cast by the pillar and their interaction with the markings, one could accurately tell the time.

His philosophical ideas left a lasting imprint on the development of Greek thought and Western philosophy. He was crucial in the transition from mythological explanations to a more systematic and rational approach to understanding the natural world.

Anaximander of Miletus stands as a foundational figure in the history of philosophy. His ideas on the apeiron, cosmology, and biology challenged traditional beliefs and paved the way for future generations of thinkers to explore the mysteries of the universe.

His legacy survives as a testament to human curiosity, intellectual courage, and the timeless quest for understanding the world in which we live.

He is our latest ECG Hall of Fame Library addition.

Sources:

World History Encyclopedia – Joshua J. Mark

Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Wikipedia